Setauket isn’t ranked, but the towns around it are

Setauket has fewer than 2,500 residents, below the floor for New York’s town rankings: Census estimates for a town this size carry margins too wide to rank fairly. Here’s what the towns around it are known for.

The best places to live in New YorkOne score from affordability, safety, schools, health, jobs and the outdoors. Plus families, retirees and affordable picks.