B−
Shelter Island School
PublicOtherGrades PK–12
33 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964 · (631) 749-0302 · Part of Shelter Island Union Free School District
Students
183
Students per teacher
5:1
Free or reduced lunch
33%
Setting
Rural
Grades
PK–12
What stands out about Shelter Island School
- Small classes: 5:1 students per teacher
- Enrollment down 14.9% since 2020
Test scores
EDFacts via Urban Institute Education Data Portal (SY2020-21) · 2020–21Math proficiency52%
State average 56.1%
Reading / language arts62%
State average 62.6%
Location
Directions ↗
33 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
Students
Enrollment by grade
Pre-K18
Kindergarten14
Grade 115
Grade 29
Grade 311
Grade 411
Grade 517
Grade 613
Grade 75
Grade 813
Grade 915
Grade 1013
Grade 1118
Grade 1211
Enrollment over time
215’20
173’21
174’22
193’23
183’24
Down 14.9% since 2020.
Who goes here
White 65%Hispanic 30%Asian 2%Two or more races 2%Black <1%
As reported to NCES, share of students with a reported race or ethnicity.
What neighbors say
No ratings yet. Be the first neighbor to rate it.
Parents talk
Conversations in Town Square that mention Shelter Island School.
School facts: U.S. Department of Education (NCES), 2024-2025 school year. Scores: EDFacts via Urban Institute Education Data Portal (SY2020-21). The School Grade is our own summary of state test results. Neighbor ratings are opinions, not an official measure of school quality.