Franklin Booth
1874–1948 American artist
Kevin Plawecki
born 1991 American baseball player and coach
Zach Trotman
born 1990 American ice hockey defenceman
Cameron Schilling
born 1988 United States ice hockey player
Jake Mitchell
born 2001 American swimmer
Keeley Dowling
born 1983 American soccer player
Mark Herrmann
born 1959 All-American college football player, professional football player, quarterback, College Football Hall of Fame member
Cameron Lindley
born 1997 American soccer player
Daniel Keller
born 1992 American soccer player
Matt Elliott
born 1968 American football player
Chris Fetter
born 1985 American baseball coach
Earl Irvin West
1920–2011 American Restoration movement historian
Reece Horn
born 1993 American football wide receiver
Amy Bilquist
born 1997 American swimmer
Lee Schmidt
born 1947 American golf course architect
Thomas Revard
born 1997 American cyclist
Nate Becker
born 1996 American football player
Trey Galloway
born 2001 American basketball player
Douglas A. Lee
born 1932 American musicologist
Also called Carmel home
Rajeev Ram
born 1984 American tennis player
Scot Pollard
born 1975 American basketball player and reality television contestant
Ted Allen
born 1965 American television personality
Jim Irsay
1959–2025 American football team owner
Pete Dye
1925–2020 Golf course architect, amateur golfer
Alice Dye
1927–2019 Amateur golfer, golf course architect
Mike Delph
born 1970 American politician
Avriel Shull
1931–1976 Architect from the United States
Aaron Renn
American author and policy analyst
Megan Myrehn
born 1990 Miss Indiana USA 2012
David Dilts
American lacrosse player (Syracuse)
Eva Nico
American academic administrator
John Cohen
American lacrosse player (Syracuse)
Thomas A. Rumer
American writer