A grade needs all of the FBI's latest years (2023–2025). Carroll's police department reported only 2024 and 2025, so we don't grade it yet. The figures below are still real.

Violent crime per 1,000

Carroll 0.3

New York 3.7

U.S. 3.3

Property crime per 1,000

Carroll 2.7

New York 15.7

U.S. 15.5

FBI crime data, 2025 · crimes reported to policeCrime & safety →

Schools in Carroll

All Carroll schools →

School Grade B

The public schools Carroll’s kids attend, from kindergarten through graduation, outperform 63% of New York’s districts on state tests and graduation. Among towns with similar incomes, they rank near the top.

#173Best public schoolsof 484 in NY

DistrictFREWSBURG CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICTSchools2

Robert H Jackson Elementary School B-Elementary · Grades PK–6 · 395 students Frewsburg Junior-Senior High School BHigh · Grades 7–12 · 335 students

School data from the U.S. Department of Education (NCES, EDFacts). The School Grade is our own summary of state test results and graduation rates, graded within NY. Ratings are from neighbors.

Famous people from CarrollWriters, athletes, leaders and more who were born in Carroll.Meet them →

Where Carroll is

Explore map →

Imported town boundary

New York · NY · Chautauqua CountyTown boundary on OpenStreetMap →

Around town

Bordering towns

Explore map →

Carroll Kiantone Poland South Valley

WKiantone NPoland ESouth Valley

Compare side by side:Carroll vs Kiantone Carroll vs Poland Carroll vs South Valley

How things work in Carroll

All explainers →

No one has written Carroll’s explainers yetKnow how one of these works here? Each explainer earns +10 karma.

Town hall & decisionsTrash, recycling & yard wasteUtilities & servicesStreets, parking & getting aroundSafety & preparednessSchools & learningParks, sports & recreationHealth & emergency care