Compare towns
Mamakating vs Wallkill vs Parma vs Crawford
Cost, people, housing, commute and schools, side by side, each benchmarked against New York.
What stands out worked out from the figures below
Mamakating has the youngest population (median age 36).
Wallkill has grown the fastest since 2010 (+11.2%).
Parma has the shortest commute (22 min average).
Crawford has the highest household income ($135k).
What matters to you?
Pick a few. We’ll pull those rows to the top and mark which town comes out ahead on each. There’s no overall score: what matters is up to you.
| Measure | Mamakating | Wallkill | Parma | Crawford |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Your priorities | ||||
| People | ||||
| Population | 12,728 |
31,023Highest |
16,111 |
9,088Lowest |
| Growth since 20102010 → 2020 census | +4.7% NY: +4.2% |
+11.2%Highest NY: +4.2% |
+3.7% NY: +4.2% |
-2%Lowest NY: +4.2% |
| Median age | 36±3Lowest 10% below NY |
41.2±2.2Highest 4% above NY |
40.4±3.3 about the NY average |
39±3.6 about the NY average |
| Wallkill and Parma are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher. | ||||
| Kids under 18 | 25.6%±3.2Highest NY: 20.5% |
20.7%±2.3Lowest NY: 20.5% |
25.6%±3.3Highest NY: 20.5% |
24.8%±4.8 NY: 20.5% |
| Age 65+ | 13.7%±2.2 NY: 17.9% |
15.7%±1.6 NY: 17.9% |
18.3%±2.1Highest NY: 17.9% |
13.2%±2.4Lowest NY: 17.9% |
| Parma and Wallkill are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher. | ||||
| Bachelor’s degree+adults 25+ | 29.9% NY: 40.2% |
28%Lowest NY: 40.2% |
35.9%Highest NY: 40.2% |
28.2% NY: 40.2% |
| Enrolled in collegeshare of residents | 2.5%±1Lowest NY: 7% |
7.8%±1.5Highest NY: 7% |
4.3%±1.2 NY: 7% |
5.4%±2 NY: 7% |
| Wallkill and Crawford are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher. | ||||
| Cost of living | ||||
| Household incomemedian | $90,631±$10kLowest 5% above NY |
$96,076±$4k 12% above NY |
$93,558±$8k 9% above NY |
$134,955±$11kHighest 57% above NY |
| Home valuemedian, owner-occupied | $246,800±$19k 42% below NY |
$353,200±$13k 17% below NY |
$220,000±$15kLowest 48% below NY |
$428,800±$34kHighest about the NY average |
| Rentmedian gross, monthly | $1,484±$168 8% below NY |
$1,790±$80Highest 10% above NY |
$1,216±$111Lowest 25% below NY |
$1,621±$399 about the NY average |
| Wallkill and Crawford are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher. | ||||
| Property taxmedian, yearly | $5,794 12% below NY |
$6,623 about the NY average |
$5,549Lowest 16% below NY |
$8,265Highest 26% above NY |
| Renters paying 30%+of income on rent | 54.1%±14.2Highest NY: 52.1% |
52.8%±8.1 NY: 52.1% |
49.8%±15.2 NY: 52.1% |
38.3%±14.7Lowest NY: 52.1% |
| Mamakating and Wallkill are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher. | ||||
| Below poverty line | 13.5%Highest NY: 14% |
11% NY: 14% |
8.1% NY: 14% |
7.8%Lowest NY: 14% |
| Housing | ||||
| Homeownersof occupied homes | 75.7% NY: 54.3% |
64.1%Lowest NY: 54.3% |
82.3%Highest NY: 54.3% |
79.6% NY: 54.3% |
| Typical home builtmedian year | 1973Lowest 14 yrs newer than NY |
1978Highest 19 yrs newer than NY |
1976 17 yrs newer than NY |
1977 18 yrs newer than NY |
| Getting to work | ||||
| Average commuteone way | 34 minHighest 4% above NY |
31 min 5% below NY |
22 minLowest 32% below NY |
31 min 4% below NY |
| Work from home | 11.3%±3.2 NY: 14.9% |
10.5%±2.9 NY: 14.9% |
10.3%±2.2Lowest NY: 14.9% |
14.7%±4.9Highest NY: 14.9% |
| Crawford and Mamakating are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher. | ||||
| Schools | ||||
| Public school scoresrank in state, math + reading | #433 of 484 in NY | #476 of 484 in NY | #88 of 484 in NY | #276 of 484 in NY |
| School district | MONTICELLO CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT | MIDDLETOWN CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT · PINE BUSH CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT | HILTON CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT | PINE BUSH CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT |
| High school in town | None in town | None in town | HILTON HIGH SCHOOL | PINE BUSH SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL |
| Students per teacherat that high school | — | — | 11.9Lowest |
14.6Highest |
| On TownTapestry | ||||
| Old photos in History | None yet | None yet | None yet | None yet |
NY average · Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates 2020–2024; 2010 & 2020 decennial census; NCES Common Core of Data. “±” is the Census margin of error. Property tax is top-coded by the Census at $10,000+. School rank compares math and reading proficiency against the state average.