What stands out worked out from the figures below

Eagle has the most kids (26.1% under 18).

Shelby has the oldest population (median age 45).

What matters to you?

Pick a few. We’ll pull those rows to the top and mark which town comes out ahead on each. There’s no overall score: what matters is up to you.

Raising kidsAffordabilityOwning a homeShort commuteWorking from homeYounger crowdSettled, older crowdGrowing town

Measure	Eagle	Shelby
People
Population	1,231Lowest	4,858Highest
Growth since 20102010 → 2020 census	-7.3%Highest NY: +4.2%	-7.7%Lowest NY: +4.2%
Median age	37.8±12.6Lowest 5% below NY	45±3.2Highest 13% above NY
	Shelby and Eagle are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher.
Kids under 18	26.1%±9.9Highest NY: 20.5%	17%±3.8Lowest NY: 20.5%
	Eagle and Shelby are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher.
Age 65+	16.7%±1.4Lowest NY: 17.9%	22.6%±3.5Highest NY: 17.9%
Bachelor’s degree+adults 25+	11.2%Lowest NY: 40.2%	18.7%Highest NY: 40.2%
Enrolled in collegeshare of residents	2.8%±1.4Highest NY: 7%	1.2%±0.8Lowest NY: 7%
	Eagle and Shelby are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher.
Cost of living
Household incomemedian	$72,778±$19kHighest 15% below NY	$65,655±$14kLowest 24% below NY
	Eagle and Shelby are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher.
Home valuemedian, owner-occupied	$148,900±$41kHighest 65% below NY	$136,000±$29kLowest 68% below NY
	Eagle and Shelby are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher.
Rentmedian gross, monthly	$736±$101Lowest 55% below NY	$788±$214Highest 51% below NY
	Shelby and Eagle are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher.
Property taxmedian, yearly	$2,753Lowest 58% below NY	$3,903Highest 41% below NY
Renters paying 30%+of income on rent	54.7%±33Highest NY: 52.1%	30.9%±12.3Lowest NY: 52.1%
	Eagle and Shelby are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher.
Below poverty line	14.8%Highest NY: 14%	12.5%Lowest NY: 14%
Housing
Homeownersof occupied homes	80.6%Highest NY: 54.3%	67.8%Lowest NY: 54.3%
Typical home builtmedian year	1978Highest 19 yrs newer than NY	1943Lowest 16 yrs older than NY
Getting to work
Average commuteone way	30 minHighest 8% below NY	26 minLowest 19% below NY
Work from home	11.1%±6.5Lowest NY: 14.9%	12.5%±5.3Highest NY: 14.9%
	Shelby and Eagle are within the Census margin of error here, so we can’t say which is really higher.
Schools
Public school scoresrank in state, math + reading	—	#401 of 484 in NY
School district	—	MEDINA CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT
High school in town	—	MEDINA JUNIOR-SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
Students per teacherat that high school	—	10.6
On TownTapestry
Old photos in History	None yet	None yet

NY average · Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates 2020–2024; 2010 & 2020 decennial census; NCES Common Core of Data. “±” is the Census margin of error. Property tax is top-coded by the Census at $10,000+. School rank compares math and reading proficiency against the state average.